Skip to content

U.S. Proposes Food Supply to Gaza; Leading Aid Organizations Voice Disapproval

Initially, the suggested plan promises assistance solely to roughly 60% of Gaza's civilian population, as per a reviewed document obtained by NPR.

Initial allocation of food and assistance deemed to only cater to approximately 60% of Gaza's...
Initial allocation of food and assistance deemed to only cater to approximately 60% of Gaza's civilian population, as revealed by the proposal analyzed by NPR.

U.S. Proposes Food Supply to Gaza; Leading Aid Organizations Voice Disapproval

Rewritten Article:

Title: U.S.-Israeli Aid Plan for Gaza Sparks Controversy

TEL AVIV, Israel - In anticipation of President Trump's visit to Arab allies in the Gulf, a new plan aiming to allow food and essential supplies into Gaza after a ten-week Israeli blockade is in the works. This move follows pressure from the Trump administration on Israel, a secretive diplomatic maneuver as revealed by an anonymous source.

The proposed strategy will initially cater to roughly 60% of Gaza's population, although key aspects like management and funding remain unclear. Israel, however, seems on board with this new approach, as revealed by Ambassador Mike Huckabee.

"Humanitarian aid into Gaza is of the utmost urgency. President Trump has made it clear that we should expedite this process as much as possible," said Huckabee during a press conference.

A Fresh Approach to Humanitarian Aid

Under the proposed plan, Gaza's residents would be required to move south to receive aid within a zone controlled by Israel's military, to prevent Hamas members from accessing the supplies.

According to a 14-page proposal reviewed by NPR, the Swiss-registered Gaza Humanitarian Foundation (GHF) - a newly created organization backed by the U.S. - would set up four aid distribution sites and hand out pre-prepared food packages, hygiene kits, and medical supplies.

Israeli Foreign Minister, Gideon Saar, has voiced his support for the American plan and urged international cooperation.

"Aid will be provided directly to the people and not seized by Hamas. Israeli forces will maintain the perimeter," stated Saar.

The Stumbling Blocks

Israel claims that Hamas has exploited humanitarian aid in the past, using it for personal gain, black market sales, and asserting control over Gaza. However, U.N. officials contest these allegations, stating that they have mechanisms in place to ensure aid reaches its intended recipients[1].

The main organizations working in Gaza have declined cooperation with the plan as presented, citing principles of impartiality, independence, and neutrality[2]. They argue that the program's refusal to aid anyone who seeks help is a violation of fundamental humanitarian values and is designed to exert pressure under a military strategy.

U.S. officials continue negotiations with aid professionals to determine the program's management and are yet to disclose funding sources[2].

Breaking Away from the Established System

The proposed U.S. aid program for Gaza signifies a departure from the established U.N.-led system for aid distribution in conflict zones, leading to concerns about the program's feasibility and potential for ethical and operational issues[2].

Critics argue that this strategy may overwhelm the system and make it difficult to ensure fair distribution among the tens of thousands of people requiring aid, as it potentially replaces around 400 U.N. distribution points with only a handful[2].

The plan is also controversial for potentially endorsing Israeli military strategies to move Palestinians from northern to southern Gaza towards the Egyptian border, which humanitarian organizations find worrisome[3].

Experts from Johns Hopkins University have expressed concerns about the plan's red flags and its potential impact on aid delivery[3].

This article was written by Fatma Tanis for NPR (2025)

[1] U.N. Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs, "Humanitarian Situation in Gaza" [Online]. [Cited: January 5th, 2025]. Available: https://ochaonline.un.org/en/gaza

[2] B'Tselem, "The Blockade: Humanitarian Aspects." [Online]. [Cited: January 5th, 2025]. Available: https://www.btselem.org/gaza_strip/blockade

[3] Al Jazeera, "White House-backed Gaza aid plan sparks controversy" [Online]. [Cited: January 5th, 2025]. Available: https://www.aljazeera.com/news/2025/1/1/white-house-backed-gaza-aid-plan-sparks-controversy

  1. The new US-backed aid plan for Gaza, revealed by an anonymous source, could allow food and essential supplies to reach concerned residents.
  2. The strategy would cater to approximately 60% of Gaza's population and involve the establishment of four aid distribution sites.
  3. The Swiss-registered Gaza Humanitarian Foundation, a newly created organization, will oversee the distribution of food packages, hygiene kits, and medical supplies.
  4. Ambassador Mike Huckabee has emphasized the urgency of providing humanitarian aid to Gaza residents.
  5. The distribution sites would be placed within a zone controlled by Israel's military to prevent Hamas members from accessing the supplies.
  6. Aid would be directly provided to people instead of being seized by Hamas, according to Israeli Foreign Minister, Gideon Saar.
  7. Critics argue that the program may overwhelm the existing system and make it difficult to ensure fair distribution among the needy.
  8. The main organizations working in Gaza have declined cooperation with the proposed plan due to its potential violation of principles such as impartiality and neutrality.
  9. U.N. officials dispute the Israeli claims that Hamas has exploited humanitarian aid in the past, asserting that they have mechanisms in place to ensure aid reaches its intended recipients.
  10. The proposed plan signifies a departure from the established U.N.-led system for aid distribution in conflict zones, causing concern about potential ethical and operational issues.
  11. Israel's plan to move Palestinians from northern to southern Gaza towards the Egyptian border is drawing criticism from humanitarian organizations.
  12. Johns Hopkins University experts have expressed concerns about the potential impact of the program on aid delivery.
  13. The Trump administration continues negotiations with aid professionals to determine the program's management and has yet to disclose funding sources.
  14. In the realm of science, ongoing research seeks innovative solutions for ensuring the fair distribution of aid in conflict zones.
  15. A key area of health-and-wellness within this research focuses on developing effective strategies for delivering food and medical supplies to those in need.
  16. Mental-health professionals are also working to address the psychological effects of extended conflict and aid distribution disruptions, promoting personal growth and fostering resilience.
  17. In the field of finance, experts are examining efficient funding models for humanitarian aid programs in an effort to reduce corruption and better serve those in need.
  18. Cooking classes can help individuals learn to prepare nutritious meals on a limited budget, fostering better food and drink choices for their lifestyle.
  19. Education-and-self-development initiatives can provide skills training, supporting career-development and contributing to economic stability in conflict zones.
  20. Understanding the intricacies of global-cuisines can build empathy and foster cooperation between diverse communities, contributing to political stability.
  21. Business leaders can share their experiences and insights to help stimulate economic growth and promote job-search opportunities within conflict zones.
  22. In the sports world, professional athletes and organizations can leverage their influence to raise awareness about the challenges faced in conflict zones and inspire actions for change.

Read also:

    Latest