In Bavaria's Shadows: The Creeping Threat of Regional Blackouts as Green Transition Outpaces Grid Expansion
- *
Expansion of the network at a slow pace could potentially lead to increased instances of power outages in local areas. - Sluggish growth in network infrastructure could lead to enhanced chances of local power blackouts.
In the heart of Germany, a menacing specter looms, its presence growing stronger - the risk of regional power outages, particularly in Bavaria. This grim forecast is a side-effect of the state's rapid transition to solar energy, racing past the expansion of the grid, which struggles to keep pace. A revelation from the Federal Network Agency's data sheds light on the escalating stakes: solar power that's generated in abundance, only to be essentially wasted.
The Doomsday Scenario Looms Closer
"The ever-quickening expansion of solar power far outstrips the expansion of the grid, both in the transmission and distribution networks," asserts Marian Rappl, CEO of the Association of Bavarian Energy and Water Industry (VBEW). "Simultaneously, the probability of targeted, regional, and time-limited shutdowns of equipment according to Section 13.2 of the Energy Industry Act has significantly increased compared to previous years." Should a power outage occur, many would find themselves plunged into darkness.
A Word of Assurance from Munich
"While restrictions on power supply due to grid bottlenecks and simultaneous renewable energy excesses are unlikely, according to a Munich Ministry of Economics spokeswoman, it's a scenario worth keeping an eye on, for the stakes are high."
The Approaching Reckoning
"We're currently managing situations like generation peaks through foresighted measures," explains Rappl. "However, the power industry remains guarded against potential scenarios that may require the implementation of extreme measures as stipulated by Section 13.2 of the EnWG, colloquially known as 'controlled load shedding'."
In extreme cases, such measures can translate to temporary regional separations of the grid elements, a last resort that would only be resorted to when all other conventional methods have failed.
The Unfortunate Tangle of Circumstances
"When you have a chain of unfavorable factors combining, it may necessitate the application of Section 13.2 measures in exceptional cases," reveals a Tennet spokesperson from Bayreuth. Simple examples include bottlenecks in the nationwide transmission grid coinciding with very high solar energy generation in Bavaria and reaching a simultaneous low consumption point.
The Growing Cost of Grid Congestion in Bavaria
The cost of managing regular network congestion has skyrocketed in Bavaria in recent years. According to the Federal Network Agency, 986 gigawatt hours of Bavarian solar energy were curtailments in 2024, amounting to almost a terawatt-hour. In total, solar installations in Bavaria generated around 20.5 terawatt hours in that year, according to Fraunhofer Institute for Solar Energy Systems (ISE) estimates.
Not a Storm, But a Hurricane Built Over Decades
"Modern-day challenges are the fruit of many years of labor – and not just any labor. The backstory: After the nuclear disaster in Japan in 2011, Horst Seehofer, then Minister President of Bavaria, and his successor Markus Söder (CSU) were among the leading proponents advocating for the acceleration of the previously postponed nuclear phase-out to 2022," states our source.
As nuclear power plants shut down, power lines remained in limbo, unbuilt. To compensate for the loss, plans for new high-voltage power lines from North to South Germany were hastily drawn up. Despite opposition from sections of the population and 'Monster Line' opponent Hubert Aiwanger, the CSU leadership pushed through the underground construction of the originally planned overhead lines for the 'Suedlink' and 'Suedostlink' projects. These underground cables make both lines much more expensive and delay their completion by years.
The Planned Lines Were Meant for Yesterday
Originally, these lines were intended to be operational by 2022, in time for the nuclear phase-out. However, they are now scheduled to go live in 2027 (Suedostlink) and 2028 (Suedlink). The last nuclear power plants were shut down in April 2023.
The Widening Power Gap in Bavaria
"A consequence of the early nuclear phase-out, championed by Seehofer and Söder, is a yawning gap in Bavaria's power generation, as predicted expertly over a decade ago," informs our source. According to estimates by the Fraunhofer ISE, in 2024, Bavaria generated around 59 terawatt hours but consumed nearly 77 terawatt hours.
While the State Government Urges Swift Power Line Construction and Nuclear Revival, Opposition Shifts Positions
"Meanwhile, the state government calls for swift power line construction, and during the federal election campaign, Söder also called for the reactivation of nuclear power plants. Even Hubert Aiwanger, now Minister of Economic Affairs, has softened his stance on power lines," our source adds.
Nor does the VBEW or Tennet criticize the CSU or Free Voters. Nonetheless, the current troubles would be significantly alleviated if the two lines were already operational, assures the Tennet spokesperson. "Upon the commissioning of all our network reinforcement and expansion projects, there is a clear relief in congestion management," they say, noting that this would be especially true for large projects like Suedlink and Suedostlink.
Yet Solar Energy Continues to Blaze its Trail in Bavaria
"All in all, we can expect a further robust increase in solar power capacity in Bavaria by the end of 2025," shares a spokesperson from the Bavarian Ministry of Economic Affairs in Munich.
Overall:Several interrelated factors give rise to the growing threat of regional power outages in Bavaria, and by extension, Germany:
Defining Factors
1. Grid Congestion, Coordination Challenges- Overburdened Grid: The existing grid, especially in heavily solar-populated regions like Bavaria, is not designed to handle the irregular and distributed nature of renewable energy. Redundancies in the system and the inability to effectively coordinate grid operations lead to congestion, making it difficult to transmit excess electricity to areas where it's needed or balance supply and demand across regions.- Negative Prices and Curtailments: Rapid solar expansion outstripping the grid's capacity leads to periods of high solar generation and local oversupply. This forces grid operators to curtail solar production, reducing revenue for solar operators and increasing the potential for instability at local levels.
2. Reduced Mechanical Inertia- Diminished System Stability: Traditional fossil fuel and nuclear plants provide inertia, which helps to stabilize grid frequency and prevent rapid voltage fluctuations. Solar panels and wind turbines provide little to no inertia. As Germany's grid dependence on renewables grows and its reliance on conventional plants wanes, the grid becomes more vulnerable to frequency deviations and cascading outages.- Enhanced Susceptibility to Shocks: The European blackout in Iberia underscores that high penetration of renewables, especially without adequate system inertia or backup capacity, can lead to grid instability and, in extreme cases, regional blackouts.
3. Energy Storage and Flexibility Shortages- Insufficient Battery Storage: Solar energy is intermittent, and without adequate battery storage or other forms of flexibility (such as demand response), excess generation cannot be stored or shifted to times when it's needed most. This exacerbates grid congestion and increases the risk of outages during periods of low renewable output or high demand.- Delayed Deployment of Energy Storage Solutions: The industry's slow adoption of battery energy storage systems (BESS) means that the grid cannot yet fully take advantage of stored solar energy to balance the system.
4. Infrastructural and Policy Delays- Sluggish Grid Expansion: The process of building new transmission lines or upgrading existing ones is complex and time-consuming, often incurring regulatory and public opposition. These delays mean that the physical infrastructure cannot keep pace with the rapid increase in renewable generation capacity.- Uncertain Market and Policy Landscape: Volatile electricity prices and an unpredictable regulatory environment complicate grid planning, making it more difficult to address emerging bottlenecks in a timely manner.
Comprehensive Overview
| Key Challenge | Detailed Description ||---------------------------------------|-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------|| Grid Congestion/Coordination Challenges | Overburdened grid and lack of coordination lead to congestion and local oversupply, forcing curtailments and increasing the risk of instability. || Reduced Mechanical Inertia | Diminished system stability makes the grid more vulnerable to frequency deviations and cascading outages. The recent European blackout in Iberia illustrates this. || Energy Storage and Flexibility Shortages | Insufficient battery storage and slow adoption of BESS mean the grid cannot store or shift excess renewable energy, leading to grid congestion. || Infrastructural and Policy Delays | Delays in grid expansion and unpredictable policy landscape hinder timely relief from grid bottlenecks and imbalances. |
The Bottom Line
The risks of regional power outages in Bavaria rise as the state transitions to solar energy, outpacing grid expansion. Balancing renewable energy generation with grid infrastructure, energy storage, and complementary technologies is essential to maintain stability as the share of renewables continues to grow.
- The risk of regional power outages, particularly in Bavaria, is becoming more pronounced due to the state's rapid transition to solar energy.
- The expansion of solar power generation far outpaces the expansion of the grid, both in transmission and distribution networks.
- The chance of targeted, regional, and time-limited shutdowns of equipment according to Section 13.2 of the Energy Industry Act has significantly increased compared to previous years.
- Should a power outage occur, many would find themselves plunged into darkness.
- While restrictions on power supply due to grid bottlenecks and simultaneous renewable energy excesses are unlikely, according to a Munich Ministry of Economics spokeswoman, it's a scenario worth keeping an eye on.
- The power industry remains guarded against potential scenarios that may require the implementation of extreme measures as stipulated by Section 13.2 of the EnWG.
- In extreme cases, such measures can translate to temporary regional separations of the grid elements, a last resort that would only be resorted to when all other conventional methods have failed.
- The cost of managing regular network congestion has skyrocketed in Bavaria in recent years.
- In 2024, 986 gigawatt hours of Bavarian solar energy were curtailments, amounting to almost a terawatt-hour.
- The backstory of the current situation is after the nuclear disaster in Japan in 2011, Horst Seehofer, then Minister President of Bavaria, and his successor Markus Söder (CSU) were among the leading proponents advocating for the acceleration of the previously postponed nuclear phase-out to 2022.
- As nuclear power plants shut down, power lines remained in limbo, unbuilt.
- To compensate for the loss, plans for new high-voltage power lines from North to South Germany were hastily drawn up.
- Despite opposition from sections of the population and 'Monster Line' opponent Hubert Aiwanger, the CSU leadership pushed through the underground construction of the originally planned overhead lines for the 'Suedlink' and 'Suedostlink' projects.
- These underground cables make both lines much more expensive and delay their completion by years.
- The last nuclear power plants were shut down in April 2023.
- A consequence of the early nuclear phase-out, championed by Seehofer and Söder, is a yawning gap in Bavaria's power generation.
- According to estimates by the Fraunhofer ISE, in 2024, Bavaria generated around 59 terawatt hours but consumed nearly 77 terawatt hours.
- While the State Government Urges Swift Power Line Construction and Nuclear Revival, Opposition Shifts Positions.
- Solar Energy Continues to Blaze its Trail in Bavaria.
- Several interrelated factors give rise to the growing threat of regional power outages in Bavaria, and by extension, Germany:
- Grid Congestion, Coordination Challenges
- Reduced Mechanical Inertia
- Energy Storage and Flexibility Shortages
- Infrastructural and Policy Delays
- The risks of regional power outages in Bavaria rise as the state transitions to solar energy, outpacing grid expansion. Balancing renewable energy generation with grid infrastructure, energy storage, and complementary technologies is essential to maintain stability as the share of renewables continues to grow.
