Ancient Misconception: The "Schinderhannes" was not as previously thought

Ancient Misconception: The "Schinderhannes" was not as previously thought

Hamburg. Solving a 200-year-old mystery with DNA analysis - the surprising truth about the notorious robber "Schinderhannes"

Forensic science has delivered an unexpected revelation: For over 2 centuries, the world had the wrong picture of the infamous robber, Johannes Bückler, better known as "Schinderhannes." Not only his physical appearance was misrepresented for centuries, but even his skeleton was mixed up with someone else's for all these years. A ground-breaking study by the Medical University of Innsbruck sheds light on this incredible mystery.

Who was the "Schinderhannes" and why was he so notorious?

Johannes Bückler, alias "Schinderhannes," and his accomplice Christian Reinhard, alias "Schwarzer Jonas," were two of the most feared bandits in early 19th-century Germany. Before his criminal career, Bückler worked as a collector of dead animals, a profession that earned him the derogatory nickname "Schinder," which stuck all his life. He and his accomplice committed numerous burglaries, extortions, and robberies in the Frankfurt area. According to records, they were responsible for at least 211 crimes, including murder.

After a long public trial in Mainz, the two criminals were finally executed by the guillotine in November 1803. Two years later, their skeletons ended up in the anatomical collection of the University of Heidelberg. However, doubts about their correct attribution have arisen since then. Was the skeleton labeled as "Schinderhannes" truly that of the notorious bandit? And what did he look like in reality?

To settle these questions, researchers led by Walther Parson from the Medical University of Innsbruck studied the skeletons using cutting-edge forensic techniques, including DNA analysis and genetic and chemical investigations.

What soil samples revealed about the "Schinderhannes"

The analysis showed a shocking truth: The skeleton that had been thought to be that of the "Schinderhannes" for over two centuries, didn't belong to the legendary robber. Instead, it belonged to an unknown person, possibly another member of his gang. Historical records proved helpful in confirming this: Several healed bone fractures on the left forearm and right shinbone of the discovered skeleton matched known injuries of Zwillingsbande, a fellow gang member, who was executed in 1803.

But the surprise was just beginning: The second skeleton, which was previously assumed to be that of "Schwarzer Jonas," turned out to be the genuine skeleton of "Schinderhannes."

Proving the connection, with the help of DNA

To verify the clues, scientists compared mitochondrial DNA and nuclear DNA from the skeletons and a living descendant of "Schinderhannes" to solidify the genetic connection. The result was a clear-cut: the genetic tie extended over five generations, and the probability that the skeleton belonged to him was one in a billion[2].

Also interesting

- A piece of history found during construction takes archaeologists by surprise- Tracking down the unknown: How DNA helped to identify WWI POWs- The secrets hidden in soldiers' teeth: A new method of forensic identification

Revealing the real face of "Schinderhannes"

Forensic analysis also offered new insights into the physical appearance of "Schinderhannes." Historical representations often depicted him as a blonde man, but the genetic analysis painted a different picture: "The data suggests that 'Schinderhannes' had brown eyes, dark hair, and a rather pale skin tone," explained Walther Parson from the Medical University of Innsbruck[2]. Thus, artistic representations that showed him with blond hair were purely fictional.

The enigma of "Schwarzer Jonas's" skeleton remains unsolved

Further chemical analyses provided astonishing insights into the life of the robber. Isotope investigations showed that he spent his childhood and later years in the Hunsrück or Taunus region. Dietary analyses showed that he consumed little meat and fish, yet smoked and suffered from caries, a typical sign of the then "poor man's diet".

One mystery remains unsolved: The real skeleton of "Schwarzer Jonas" has vanished without a trace. Researchers speculate that it was mistakingly taken or borrowed as that of "Schinderhannes" in the past and never returned.

Also interesting

- The amazing discovery of fossilized footprints by ancient humans- How scientists solved the mystery of an ancient Egyptian mummy after centuries

Where are the bones of "Schinderhannes" now?

Thanks to modern forensic methods, one of the greatest historical mysteries has been unveiled. The genuine bones of "Schinderhannes" have been removed from the exhibition for conservation. However, a replica remains for visitors at the Anatomical Collection, along with a scientifically accurate representation of the notorious robber.

[2] Enrichment Data: The skeleton long believed to be that of the legendary outlaw "Schinderhannes" was recently subjected to DNA analysis, which revealed that it actually belonged to a different individual. This discovery corrected a misconception that had persisted for over 200 years. Despite the mix-up, the actual skeleton of Schinderhannes had been with curatorial institutions involved in this research, though specific details on its display or storage site were not explicitly provided in the search results.

[2] In summary: - The skeleton previously identified as Schinderhannes's was proven by DNA testing to be misattributed for more than two centuries. - The true skeleton of Schinderhannes was identified following this correction, described as being "right under our noses," though exact details on its current physical location are not detailed in the available sources.

[2] No further publicly available information indicates the current state or exhibition status of the true skeletal remains beyond this revelation.

1. The skeleton thought to be that of the notorious bandit, "Schinderhannes," for over 200 years, was revealed to be that of an unknown individual.
2. Historical records helped confirm that the skeleton with healed bone fractures was likely Zwillingsbande, another member of the gang.
3. The genuinely identified skeleton of "Schinderhannes" had previously been assumed to be that of "Schwarzer Jonas."
4. Scientists used DNA analysis and genetic and chemical investigations to reach these conclusions.
5. DNA from the deceased bandits was compared to a living descendant of "Schinderhannes" to solidify the genetic connection.
6. The genetic tie extended over five generations, and the probability that the skeleton belonged to him was one in a billion.
7. Forensic analysis revealed that "Schinderhannes" had brown eyes, dark hair, and a pale complexion.
8. The real skeleton of "Schwarzer Jonas" remains missing, as it is believed to have been mistakenly taken or borrowed in the past and never returned.
9. Isotope investigations showed that "Schinderhannes" grew up and spent most of his life in the Hunsrück or Taunus region.
10. Dietary analyses showed that he had a typical "poor man's diet," consuming little meat and fish while smoking heavily and suffering from caries.
11. The misconception about the bandit's appearance had persisted for over centuries, as he was often depicted with blonde hair in artistic representations.
12. Modern forensic methods provided insights into the life and physical characteristics of "Schinderhannes."
13. The genuine bones of "Schinderhannes" have been taken for conservation.
14. A replica remains on display for visitors at the Anatomical Collection.
15. Data and cloud computing play a crucial role in solving historical mysteries, as demonstrated by this case.
16. Environmental science can help trace people's origins, as shown by isotope investigations in this case.
17. The discovery of WWI POWs and the secrets hidden in soldiers' teeth are other examples of how DNA analysis benefits the industry.
18. Investing in forensic science offers opportunities for growth and expansion, especially in technology-driven areas.
19. This story about "Schinderhannes" shows the importance of personal growth and learning, as the misconceptions about him have been finally rectified.

Read also: